Season 1

Anna Borntregger has been dead for 10 years, so when her husband suddenly tells police he murdered her they don't know what to make of his confession

When the body of a 9-year-old boy is found by the side of a rural highway it takes police two years to identify him. The mystery leads police on a chilling odyssey into a secretive community and hot on the trail of an Amish serial killer.

When a young Amish wife is found murdered in her bed, police uncover a dark world they never imagine existed.

Naomi Huyard never strayed far from home, so her sudden vanishing rocks her tight-knit community to it's core. When detectives make an unspeakable discovery, they soon realize there's much more to the story than meets the eye.

When Katie Gingerich is found murdered and disemboweled, even the most hardened police are shocked. A conflict of faith in the strict Amish community could have led to such a brutal act.

When a Mennonite family man is stopped for drunk-driving, no one could predict that it would expose a shocking underbelly of organized crime. Abraham Wiebe risks it all as a central figure in one of the largest criminal cases in Oklahoma history