The preachers' daughters prove they are anything but angels when Taylor reveals one of her fantasies, Olivia questions the paternity of her daughter and Kolby asks for permission to begin dating.
Olivia finds out the results of the paternity test, Taylor lies to her parents and attends a party with boys, and Kolby and her family are shocked by her sister's confession.
As Kolby questions her beliefs about premarital sex, Olivia meets with a lawyer after contacting her baby's father and Taylor is put to the test when a new boy comes into her life.
Olivia introduces a boy from her past to her parents. Nikita asks his daughters' to assist him in rekindling his relationship with their mother. Taylor attends a double date with her parents.
Kolby reevaluates her relationship with Micah. Taylor is distraught after her father falls victim to a health scare. Olivia learns some hidden secrets about Frankie.
Olivia is at odds with her parents over their beliefs on Halloween while Kolby celebrates her first Halloween with a house party. Taylor and Marie keep the church going while Ken is in the hospital.
Kolby and her sisters have a girls weekend out and things get a bit unholy. Taylor is forced to attend a purity class. Olivia flies to Los Angeles in order to visit her sister and take part in a photo shoot.
Olivia is asked to lead an outing for troubled teens. Kolby's mother reveals a secret from her past. Taylor and her father visit a Christian college
Taylor's parents throw her a birthday party that gets wild as the night goes on while Victoria loosens her grip on Kolby dating. Olivia worries that her past could have lasting effects on her daughter.
The Perrys, Colemans and Koloffs sit down on the couch again to reveal never-before-seen moments from Season One. They'll also revisit some of the classic moments from the series with hilarious and heartwarming commentary.